Gino started snickering through his nose.
“You’ve been following me,” I said again. My voice sounded far away; it was buckling with incredulity. “For how long?”
“Too long,” they said together.
“Nic was against it, if that makes it any easier to stomach. He’s been fighting to leave you out of this,” Dom said with mock sympathy. “But it is what it is.”
“Out of what?”
“Fighting and losing,” Gino sneered, ignoring my question.
“But,” added Dom, “if we hadn’t been following you, you probably would have been raped that night after the world’s most boring party.”
“Oh my God.” Horror curled in my stomach. “That’s how Luca found me.”
“He wasn’t supposed to intervene,” said Dom, his voice suddenly disapproving. “We weren’t allowed to do anything that would disrupt your day unless your uncle made an appearance, but Luca broke the rules, like he always does. We didn’t even know about it until you came around shouting in our driveway.”
I blanched. Gino seemed to disengage from the conversation, and his attention started to wander around the darkened room. At a sound from outside, Dom glanced past me through a crack in the curtains. I seized the brothers’ momentary distraction and slid around the wall until I was nearer to the door.
They drifted with me like tracking drones.
“I wouldn’t if I were you,” lisped Gino. “I don’t want to hit a girl. Even if it is you.”
“You’re going to have to come with us.” Dom sounded almost apologetic, but it did little to soothe my slow-burning hatred for him. Not only had he broken into my house and was trying to take me somewhere against my will, but he had obviously used Millie and then dumped her, and that made him a total, unredeemable asshole. I slid into the open doorway, but Gino blocked me in an instant. He shot his arm out, covering the sliver of space.
Dom curled around the other side of me, closing in. He glanced at his brother and gave him a controlled nod. Gino dropped to his hands and knees and slithered across the floor like a reptile, swiping his hand around as he crawled. It was completely, unnecessarily dramatic.
I tried to run, but Dom grabbed my arm and pulled me back. “Don’t.”
Finally, Gino fished out my phone from underneath the armchair and sprang to his feet, dangling it in the air between us. “Gotcha,” he said triumphantly to Dom.
Dom took the phone and held it to his ear. “Jackie boy?” he sneered. The distant sound of shouting filled my ears. “I think it’s time we finished this.”
Laughing to himself, Gino shuffled to my side. “Time for Sophie to say bye-bye.” His smile revealed his two chipped teeth, and his tongue poked out beneath them. I was still straining to hear what Jack was saying when Gino’s hands disappeared from my view.
Dom covered the mouthpiece and redirected to his brother. “Hurry up,” he said.
The damp rag came out of nowhere.
“And where the offense is, let the great axe fall.”
WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE, Hamlet
I could hear buzzing. It made the world vibrate, pulsing inside my eardrums until it felt like the bees were coming from inside my skull. I twitched awake. The sweetest cacophony of smells hung in the air, coaxing me from the darkness that had engulfed me so completely. I opened my eyes to a white ceiling and felt a horrible tightness in my chest.
I groaned.
“Ah, you’re awake, at last. I was wondering how long that would take to wear off.”
I didn’t have to turn my head in the direction of the voice to know who it belonged to. It was unusually soft for a man’s tone, and each syllable was pronounced with overexaggerated precision, betraying his faint Italian accent.
“Felice,” I said. I tried to sit up, but I couldn’t. My arms and legs were bound together by cable ties; they cut into my wrists and squeezed the bottom of my bare ankles uncomfortably. “Where am I?”
“Generally? You are in Lake Forest. Specifically? You are reclining on my couch.”
The leather squeaked as I heaved my clasped hands toward my bound legs and pulled them together, crunching into an upright position. I swiveled my body around, dropping my knees over the couch and placing my hands in my lap as a streak of white sunlight slashed across my vision, making my eyelids flutter.
I was almost level with an open bay window across the room. The sun was beginning to dip in the pink-tinged sky — I must have been out for a long time. I could tell I was at least one story up. Outside, there was an old wooden barn tucked behind a sprawling garden with vibrant flowers that faded into open fields. Tens of small wooden sheds dotted the grass in regimented lines.