That was because there was no room. As she kissed Jay, Riley’s fingers slid between them and twirled her nipples. The combination of both cocks inside her, kissing Jay’s wonderful mouth, and having Riley play with her nipples set her world spinning.
Jay grunted, and when Riley eased out of her rear Jay edged in, filling the space. She and Jay kissed and then nipped at each other’s lips. The playful and tender way he touched her made her want him more, especially when he nibbled on her earlobe and then left a trail of kisses down her neck. All throughout this wonderful excursion, the two men seesawed in and out of her. Even her heartbeat took on the new, exciting rhythm.
Riley reached under her and wiggled her clit, and it was like he’d struck a match to her tinder. No longer could she keep from moving. She dropped down onto Jay and Riley plowed in, stretching her way past her tolerance. “Fuck me,” she blurted.
She hadn’t meant that literally, but the men sure took it that way. Jay’s teeth sharpened as he pummeled into her, his eyes shining as yellow and bright as the sun.
“I’m about to burst,” Riley groaned out.
On the next thrust, it was as if the volcano inside her erupted—first Riley and then Jay. Stars swam in front of her eyes and her hearing dimmed as blood pounded in her ears. Desire, lust, and passion kept exploding as she screamed their names.
Fully sated, she collapsed on top of Jay just as Riley withdrew and rolled to the side. No one said anything. Exhausted and happy, she closed her eyes for a moment. Next thing she remembered was Jay dragging a wet cloth between her legs.
She opened her eyes to see him smiling and Riley looking… scared perhaps? Though she couldn’t imagine why.
“That was fantastic,” she said, though if she’d had her wits about her, she could have come up with a better word.
“It was more than that,” Jay said leaning down and kissing her again.
“We should let you rest,” Riley said. “Be careful at work tomorrow. I’ll keep an eye on Russ, too.”
They had just shared the hottest sex of her life and he was just going to up and leave? As if that wasn’t ticking her off enough, he had to spoil the euphoria by bringing up that ass’s name.
Fully dressed, he turned to leave then stopped, spun on his heels, and lasered a glare at Jay whose jaw tightened. Damn men were talking behind her back and she didn’t like being left out of the loop.
“If you have something to say, Riley, spit it out,” she said.
He exhaled. “I don’t think it’s a good idea that I continue seeing you like this. It messes with my head.”
Sarah didn’t know if she should be flattered or pissed. “You couldn’t have figured that out after the first time we had sex?” That might have come out a bit harsh, but now that she’d been with both, she didn’t want it to end.
“I’ll see you tomorrow, Sarah.”
She would have jumped off the bed and given him a piece of her mind had Jay not grabbed her hand. “Leave him be.”
Her heart sank even further when the door closed. Well, that sucked.
Chapter Twelve
Jay reached out to her. “Ignore him. Riley’s just confused, that’s all.”
“Confused? Five year olds are confused. Riley’s how old?”
Jay huffed. “He’s thirty-four, but his age isn’t his problem.”
Sarah opened her mouth then shut it. She had enough on her plate right now and didn’t need to be dealing with a man’s issues, but dammit, making love with Jay and Riley had not only been the best sex in her life, it had been the most exciting. For those few minutes, she’d felt a connection so deep that it shook her to the core.
“Let’s just forget it,” she said. Climbing out of the bed, she kept her back to Jay and dressed. If she looked at him, she’d see the pity in his eyes, and she couldn’t handle that.
Just as she finished zipping up her shorts, Jay turned her around. “We should talk.”
“I’d rather not.”
His grip on her shoulders tightened. “It’s not an option. It’s late and I’m hungry. I bet you are, too. I’d take you to dinner, but by the time we drive over to Lippett Falls, find a place and eat, it will be past both of our bedtimes, and I know you have to rise early.”
Here she’d thought Riley was the controlling one. He was right, though. “I have a pizza in the freezer. Will that do?”
Jay smiled and pleasure shot through her. Her hormones must have taken over her thought processes.
“Perfect. I’ll help.”
“There’s not much to do.” It had been a long time since she’d shared the kitchen with anyone other than her assigned roommate. “If you get the pizza out of the freezer and put it on a tray, I’ll fix us some decaf.”