Tyler reached up and cupped her breasts gently with his hands. His gaze was locked on her face when she lifted her head. His teeth were clenched, which made her smile. The waiting was tough for him. She didn’t want to wait a moment longer either, and on the next push, she slammed herself over his cock.
Tyler groaned, his eyes rolling back into his head for a moment.
Alyssa froze. Her eyes widened. She took a deep breath. The pressure was intense. Not as painful as she’d expected but so tight. Once the initial shock disappeared, the stretch felt fantastic. And the discomfort was momentary. In a few seconds she wanted more. She lifted up and let his length drag across her sensitive skin.
She moaned as her clit pressed into Tyler on her way back down. She paused, enjoying the full sensation. Tyler’s gaze returned to hers. He flicked his fingers over her nipples, sending a shiver down her spine, and then dropped his hands to his sides. His voice was deep and gravelly when he spoke again. “God, Ali. So tight.”
A sense of power made Alyssa smile. She glanced down to see Tyler fisting the sheets. Where was Michael? He’d disappeared. His touch no longer warmed her back.
“I’m right here, babe.” She twisted her head toward his voice across the room and then let her eyes close.
Luxuriating in the sensations, she lifted off Tyler and started a rhythm that made her toes curl. It felt so good. She never wanted the sensation to end. The friction was building, and her only thought was reaching the precipice.
Hands landed on her back again. She flinched as Michael smoothed his palms around her middle until he cupped her breasts from behind. When he pinched her nipples, she arched her chest forward. She was so close.
“Come, babe. Come around Ty’s cock.” Michael leaned in and nibbled on her ear before he released her breasts. “Come before we both take you at the same time.”
Alyssa moaned as he spoke. His words tickled her ear and made her clench around Tyler’s length.
Michael trailed his fingers down her center until he reached her clit. With one hand, he pressed her stomach. With the other, he pinched her nub with two fingers.
Alyssa bit her cheek to keep from screaming as she came. She pressed firmly over Tyler and gripped him with her pussy as she pulsed around him.
Heaven. She would never get enough of this. She gasped for air and leaned over Tyler to rest against his chest. She didn’t want to pull off him. And he was still rigid inside her. She wanted to keep moving.
That isn’t what she got though. Michael pressed a hand against her lower back and held her. “Stay against Tyler, Alyssa.”
Her eyes widened. Oh God. She knew good and well what Michael’s intentions were. Could she do this? Take them both?
Alyssa wanted to scream for more friction. How was that possible after the orgasm she’d just had? Instead, she let her chest relax against Tyler’s. His thumbs grazed the sides of her breasts and brought goose bumps up along her sides.
Suddenly a cool substance landed on her ass. Where had Michael conjured it from? That must have been what he was rummaging for across the room.
“Relax while I stretch you.” Michael smoothed the lube around the outer edge of her tiny hole, making her clench.
Her cheeks burned against Tyler’s chest. No matter how aroused she was and how badly she wanted this, it still embarrassed her to be penetrated by both of them so thoroughly. She’d not even had time to adjust to being taken in the front before the rear was added. But, God, how she wanted this. Wicked and unexpected ideas ran through her mind. All she knew was her need, overwhelming all other thoughts.
One finger slipped in and out of her, stretching in every direction. It felt so tight. So full. So different. She took a deep breath, trying to grasp the new sensation. How was he ever going to enter her with his cock?
Tyler whispered into her ear. “Unclench, sweet. While you’re gripping his finger, you’re squeezing my cock, and I don’t want to come yet.” His words were a mixture of serious and joking tones. She wasn’t sure how he’d managed not to come already.
“Oh God.” Nothing could have prepared her for this incredible sense of closeness with another being. She never would have believed them if someone had explained it. Tyler’s hands rubbed against her back and sides, holding her so close.
And she desperately wanted the same experience with Michael. In fact, she swiveled her head and looked up into his face. “I need you too.”
Michael froze. A tingling sensation spread from her nipples to her stomach as he gazed into her eyes.
“I want you two to claim me. I want us to be united. I don’t want to wait another day or even another minute.”