Well, he did not want to talk about that, certainly. He kept waiting for the shock of it to hit him, regret or sadness or anything besides this weird, numb relief. He’d loved Chelsea—at least, he thought he’d loved Chelsea. He didn’t know how to explain why he wasn’t sadder.
Unless, of course, Chelsea had been right.
“Just a fight,” he said finally, glancing over his shoulder and pulling out into traffic. “Not worth getting into, really. Was probably coming for a while.” He squinted into the rearview, switched lanes. “So, what should we do?”
“Do?” Gabby asked.
“Yeah,” he said. From the moment Gabby had texted, he’d felt like there was enough energy in his body to run all the way up Broadway without stopping. “It’s New York, right? We could go eat pie someplace. The Empire State Building might still be open.”
Gabby pulled one knee up, hugged it. “I kind of just want to go to sleep,” she said softly.
Ryan nodded, trying not to feel disappointed. “Fair enough,” he said. “We can do that too.”
The hotel was all the way on the other side of town, and even with the GPS it took Ryan a long time to figure out how to get them over there. It was weird how many cars there were on the road down here even in the middle of the night, FDR Drive and Brooklyn winking at them across the river. It was so different here from home. He glanced at Gabby, her body bent in on itself like a paper clip, her hair down and hiding her face. “You wanna talk about it?” he asked, trying not to sound too eager. Of course he wasn’t happy she’d gotten broken up with, if that was even what had happened. But there was a tiny part of him that wondered if this might be his chance. Both of their relationships ending on the same night, in New York City? That had to mean something, didn’t it?
“Nope,” Gabby said.
She cheered up a little bit once they parked the car in what Ryan hoped was a no-tow zone; he bought her a giant bag of sour-cream-and-onion chips and a Gatorade at a bodega, brought her upstairs to the room. “This is a nice hotel,” Gabby said, sitting on the bed and crunching thoughtfully. “Sorry you’re not going to get to use it for its intended purpose.”
“I’ll live,” Ryan said, sitting down heavily on the duvet beside her. “Did we seriously both get dumped tonight?”
“You got dumped?” Gabby asked him. Then, before Ryan could answer, “Did I get dumped?” And just like that, she started to cry.
Ryan froze. He’d seen Gabby cry exactly once before in their entire relationship, at the end of that Pixar movie about girl emotions, after which she insisted loudly and vehemently that she’d gotten pretzel salt in her eye. Seeing it now broke both his head and his heart.
“All right, sad sack,” he said, taking the bag of chips out of her hand and setting it down on the bedside table, wrapping his arms around her. She smelled like beer and like cold and like Gabby, peppermint soap and organic lotion. “You’re okay.”
“I’m too boring for her,” she said into his shirt collar. “She’s got this whole other life and all these new friends and she wants to go out and do stuff, and I can’t even be mad at her for it! It’s normal! She’s in college! I’m the one who isn’t normal.”
“You’re normal,” Ryan promised, smoothing her damp hair back. “There’s nothing boring about you. You’re the least boring person I know, honestly.”
“That’s a lie,” Gabby said. “Celia is right. I never leave the house. I’m terrible at social situations. I had a panicker as soon as I got out of your car.”
“Okay,” Ryan said. “Easy.” He rubbed her back for a minute, slow circles, the way his mom soothed the nervous dogs she worked with. Gabby was so much narrower than Chelsea, all sharp shoulder blades and bumpy spine, like she might blow away if he wasn’t careful. Like she was someone he wanted to protect. “You’re perfect, okay?”
Gabby sniffled into the crook of his shoulder. “You have to say that,” she said in a wet, muffled voice.
“I really don’t,” Ryan promised. But he let himself hold her a little tighter anyway, the two of them sitting like that for a long, quiet minute. He liked how warm she was through her T-shirt. He liked how she seemed to actually need him right now, the way she hardly ever seemed to.
He liked—oh Jesus Christ—the feeling of her warm mouth brushing against his neck.
Ryan felt himself pop an immediate boner, every nerve ending in his body screaming to urgent, hysterical life in the moment before he eased himself back away from her. “Gabby,” he said quietly, “are you drunk?”