Their Stepsister(15)

I’m up and grabbing Kayla a second before her fist can strike, and I catch Logan getting to Sarah at the same time. Thank god he’s here. I need to handle the crazy.

“Get her inside and do NOT take your eyes off her,” I snap at Logan.

He gives me a dirty smile and says, “Gladly.” That fucker would find this comical.

I have Kayla by the arms and as I’m escorting her to the edge of our property, I decide it’s time to make things clear.

“You’re never welcome within a hundred feet of any of us again. I will be filing restraining orders first thing in the morning. That woman you tried to hit is not only our stepsister but also the love of our lives. You didn’t get the polite decline from us before, so let me say this: farewell and fuck off.” With that I leave her standing outside and she looks utterly defeated. I feel sorry for her, but not sorry enough to give a shit.

I check back one more time to make sure she’s moving and I see her turn around and walk away. I’m sure she’s plotting her revenge already, but I’m so sick of being afraid of what people think. I’m ready to live my life the way I damn well want to.

I grab my wallet off the ground and I realize I was so focused on Sarah at the bar I didn’t notice Kayla was stealing my wallet. I guess she did it to have an excuse to come to my house and try her luck again. I’m always too distracted when it comes to our baby girl. I need to claim her and fix this situation.

When I walk in the door I immediately head upstairs. I know Logan has her in the middle room, Sarah’s room…our room. I open the door and see her sitting on the edge of the bed in tears. Logan is sitting beside her and looks up at me with big eyes. He doesn’t know how to handle tears.

I walk over and kneel in front of Sarah. This is the most vulnerable I’ve ever been in my life and I really hope she doesn’t rip my heart in two. “Hey,” I croon as I reach up to cup her face and wipe her tears away with my thumbs. “Don’t cry, princess. We’ve got you. It’s all okay now.”

She takes a deep breath and nods her head. She glares at me with her watery eyes and says hoarsely, “This is so fucked up, and you’re an asshole.”

“I know. I’m so sorry. I didn’t mean it. I just thought I needed to hurt you to push you away. I’ve never tasted anything as delectable and perfect as your pussy.”

I see the blush rise on her cheeks and I know I’ve embarrassed her.

“No, no, princess. We aren’t going to be embarrassed about anything anymore.” I look to Logan for confirmation and we lock eyes. We don’t always need words and there aren’t any that need to be said now. We both know what this moment means. There’s no turning back, but it’s also a commitment to a life together with Sarah. Damn all the consequences.

“Do you understand us, baby girl? This is it for us. You’re the one. Logan and I have tried to fight this and deny you. But we fell in love with you a long time ago, and it wasn’t the way big brothers should have loved you. It started a few years back and it’s why Logan and I stopped coming to see you together. In fact we stopped doing a lot of things together. Things we haven’t done in a long time. We haven’t been able to share a woman since, and I haven’t been able to touch one, even on my own.”

“Is that why you’ve been such a grumpy ass these past for years?” she asks, tartly.

“Probably. I thought being a dick would help keep you at bay a little. I thought if maybe I was an ass you wouldn’t want to be around me. A man’s dick can only take so much, and with you around I’m constantly hard. I refused to find release anywhere to punish myself for having lustful thoughts about my little stepsister. But I’m done. I’m not fighting it anymore. Are you in this with us? Logan and I will understand if you say no. We’ll die of broken hearts, but we’ll respect your feelings.”

Sarah looks at Logan and then looks at me, and a small smile creeps across her face. “So you’ve really never tasted better?”

I let out a breath I feel like I’ve been holding for years and laugh. Logan is grinning from ear to ear and this is the moment my heart clicks into place. Seeing my twin holding Sarah while I kneel in front of her. Seeing my stepsister finally become what I’ve always wanted…ours.

“I’m going to have to convince you for the rest of our lives, won’t I?” I say.

Sarah gets a naughty look on her face and stands up. She slides down her leggings and panties. She pulls off her sweater and sits back down on the bed completely naked. I’m shocked by her bold move but couldn’t be happier to see that pretty pink pussy dripping with honey. She spreads her legs a little, and I can tell she’s thinking about what she just did and starts to hesitate.