“Since when?”
“We’ve been casually texting since the house party.”
Sonofabitch. That was at least two weeks ago. Or has it been three?
“When were you going to tell me?”
An ironic laugh leaves her throat. “I wasn’t.”
“Why? I’ve been chasing you around for weeks; you’ll fuck him but you won’t fuck me?”
“This isn’t a contest, and please lower your voice.”
“Why.”
“Why what?”
“Why would you let him…” I swallow, unable to get the words out. Goddammit if this whole thing isn’t making me feel like complete and utter shit.
Her answer is a dry laugh. “Oh please—don’t tell me this bothers you. You who won’t commit. You who get hand-jobs and blowies from anyone with a pulse.” An unladylike snort. “Give me a flipping break.”
I stab a finger in her direction. “You’re fucking nuts if you think I’m going to be okay with this.”
“This has nothing to do with you.”
“Bullshit. This has everything to do with me! You moaned my name. My. Name.”
Her only response is a nonchalant shrug that makes me want to pin her to the wall and show her what she really means to me.
“Did you sleep with him to make me jealous? To bring me to heel? Because I’m telling you right now Jameson, it won’t fucking work. All it did was piss me off.”
A long, soft sigh. “He’s a nice guy, Oz. I like him. We might not be dating or a couple, but at least he’s not going to make me feel used and cheap in the morning. He won’t make me feel like a number. I’ll still have my dignity when I walk out of here.”
“What are you fucking talking about?” I poke a thumb into my chest. “I treat you with respect.”
“Calm down and lower your voice,” she hisses. “God, Sebastian, everything isn’t always about you. Did it ever occur to you that maybe I don’t want to be with someone who wants me to ride him to sex town?”
I silently count to ten and take a deep calming breath, clenching my fists at my sides. “Why won’t you let me fuck you?”
She studies me, cool, calm, and collected. Shoulders back and dignified, as if she’s already thought this through and knows the answer. “Because you say things like ‘why won’t you let me fuck you.’ You think I don’t want you? You’re wrong. I do. I lie in bed thinking of you every night; I dream of you Sebastian. But I’m not a fool. You will break my heart.”
“So this is your solution? Sleep with someone else? My freaking roommate, of all people.”
“I didn’t do this to hurt you.”
“It’s too late for that! How could you do this to me, Jameson? Tell me! I didn’t screw your roommate when I had the chance.”
Her face falls. Shoulders sag. “I guess I…wanted to feel good. I wanted pleasure. I wanted an orgasm. I haven’t had sex in forever, and Elliot was the safe choice.”
“Oh my fucking god.” My fists clench, wanting to punch the wall behind me. “This is such horse shit.”
Jameson crosses her arms. “I’ve made up my mind.”
“I’ve never lied to you about who I am.”
“And I love that about you, but—”
“But what?” I can’t keep the bitter taste out of my mouth.
“Wonderful and awful,” she whispers. “Beautiful and forgettable. That’s how you make me feel, all at the same time.”
“How can you stand there and say that? I adore you! I think you’re beautiful. I can’t go a minute without thinking about you, the way you smell and the way you’re always pulling your hair back, or tapping your pen when you’re concentrating. You drive me crazy.”
“It’s not enough.”
“Don’t do this Jameson; don’t say that shit. Please, you’re breaking my heart.”
She backs away, stepping toward my roommate’s door. “You won’t do it on purpose, Sebastian, but you’re just going to end up breaking mine.”
I swallow the hard lump in my throat. “And I suppose Elliot won’t.”
She gives her head a sad little shake. “Elliot won’t.”
And that’s the pisser of it all, right there. Elliot won’t, because Elliot is a great fucking guy who actually deserves a girl like Jameson Clark; I guess that makes me the asshole with no time, a shit ton of debt, the busted up body, and the crude temperament. The guy who sleeps with too many women, who gets sloppy drunk and receives blowjobs from strangers.
Fucking Elliot and his goddamn golden halo.
I’m going to beat the shit out of him. First, I’m going to grab him by his saggy balls. Then, I’m going to sucker punch him right in his fucking face. Then—
I shove off the wall and paste on a fake smile. “Fine. I’ll just leave you to it then. Have funsies.”
She looks devastated, shoulders falling. “It wasn’t supposed to be like this.”
I walk away, toward my bedroom at the end of the hallway, pausing when I reach my door. “Hey James?”
She’s still standing where I left her, rooted to the spot. Her chin quivers. “Yes?”
“I want you gone by morning.”
I don’t have to wait that long.
Fifteen minutes after our confrontation in the hall, I hear Elliot’s bedroom door open, the sound of muffled voices, and footfalls outside my door. They hesitate before moving down the corridor toward the entryway.
The front door opens and clicks closed. I numbly listen to every sound, still trying to figure out what the hell just happened here.
What in the actual shit happened?
Hands behind my head, bedside lamp still glowing, I stare up at the ceiling fan and—call me a sadist—do my absolute best to recount every detail of what I walked in on: Jameson moaning. Elliot’s white farmer’s-tanned ass pumping into her. Jameson’s half-hooded eyes as she comes. Her mouth forming the shape of my name as she gets banged by another dude.
I try a dozen times to piece it all together—then a dozen more, failing miserably time and again.
Jameson having sex because she wants to feel good. Having sex with someone else, because it feels good, with someone who isn’t me. Cause she wanted an orgasm and pleasure. Naked in the room next to mine, in a bed that’s not mine, in my house.
Did I mention naked?
Jameson getting railed by my roommate. In my house.
Jameson.
Elliot.
Jameson and Elliot.
Elliot finally getting laid, by Jameson, whose pants I’ve been trying to get into for weeks. Elliot, my friend, who deserves a girl like Jameson, who banged him because she wanted to feel good.
I wonder if life is going outside to have a smoke right now, because it just got done fucking me.
Fucking me hard.
Logically, none of this makes sense.
Yes, I might have come on a little strong with Jameson, but she doesn’t even know Elliot. How do you jump into bed with someone you’ve met at a party once and flirt with in a few freaking texts? Who does that!
Fine. I do.
I toss and turn, pounding my pillow into a useless lump, aware of my own hypocrisy. And yes, I might be a hypocrite, but at least I’m not exhibiting uncharacteristic behavior. Not like she is. Sleeping with strangers is what I do, what I’ve always done. It’s easy, fast, and doesn’t involve any effort.
No follow-through or emotions required.
Jameson might not be a virgin, but I can goddamn guarantee she’s doesn’t sleep around. She can’t.
Not the way I do.
Did.
Do.
Shit, shit, shit, my mind is a mess.
I can’t even form my thoughts straight, thoughts that have me sitting up and climbing out of bed and storming down the hallway to Elliot’s room. I bust through his door, not bothering to knock.
“Why did you do it?”
He’s seated on the bed in nothing but his boxers, flipping through Netflix, and the sight of his hairless bare chest pisses me off.
“Do what?”
“Don’t be obtuse,” I spit out. “You had sex with Jameson.”
“So?” Elliot’s sandy brown hair sticks up around his ears and he swipes the unkempt locks from his brow. “Since when is it a crime to have sex with a hot, willing female?”
The words ‘hot’ and ‘willing’ have the hairs on the back of my neck prickling. My fists clench at my sides, wanting to strike.
“Watch it,” I threaten as Elliot looks toward me like I’ve lost my damn mind—and maybe I have. “You watch the way you’re talking about her.”
His brows rise. “I can’t call her hot?”
“No.”
He gets up off the bed and makes his way to the closet, pulling out a sweatshirt. “Look, I don’t know what your fucking problem is, but spit it out already. It’s late and I’m spent.”
Spent?
Spent?
“I want to beat the shit out of you so fucking bad,” I growl, still rooted to my spot by the door, watching him pull the sweatshirt over his head. “Please give me a reason to beat you senseless.”
He pulls the hem down and his hands go up in surrender. “Whoa dude, I have no idea what you’re talking about—are… Shit, man. Are you dating Jameson? Is that what this is about? Did—holy shit—is she cheating on you? With me?”