He looked back at Lane, and saw that her gaze was focused elsewhere. Just past his shoulder and aimed up high.
He turned and looked, following her line of sight to the TV mounted on the wall. It was him. Cord McCaffrey. The man who had fathered the baby Lane had given birth to. The man who had given her the legion of issues that Finn had always sensed was there and knew it was best to stay well away from.
Which is why you’re stepping all over them now?
He chose to ignore that obnoxious voice. She had shown her hand. She was the one who had kissed him back. She had made it clear that she felt this attraction too. If she hadn’t done that, if she had gone stiff in his arms, if she had remained unmoved by what had passed between them, then it would be easy to leave her alone. But she’d responded to him. She put her hands under his shirt. And she’d sure as hell wanted him right back.
That changed things. It changed everything.
At least as far as the physical was concerned. Emotionally... The feelings that he saw playing across her face right now, that wounded light in her eyes, were well above his pay grade. He didn’t know the right words.
It struck him then how much their friendship was built on the connection they had in the present. Neither of them talked much about the past. And maybe that was why it worked.
He didn’t know what to say to her right now. With her face looking like that.
He might know all about secrets, secrets that you kept from everybody, even your own brothers. He might even know how to fix things. All kinds of things. The lights in Lane’s house, a tractor, a milking machine. But hell if he knew how to fix an emotional wound like this. In his experience, they were best left buried.
But hers hadn’t stayed buried. Part of that was his fault. It made him feel like he should say something, do something. But he didn’t know what.
“I would punch that guy in the face if I ever saw him,” he said, in lieu of anything comforting or insightful.
He was fresh out of comfort and insight.
“I have to go,” Lane said, pushing back from the table and walking out of the bar.
Finn watched her retreating form, then threw some money on the table, knowing that he had overpaid and not caring, and rushed out after her.
Dammit. He had said the wrong thing. But what the hell was the right thing to say?
“Lane,” he said, catching up to her in the parking lot. “What’s going on?”
She looked edgy, her eyes wide, her lower lip currently being punished by her teeth. “You know. That’s the thing. You know.”
“Is that what’s bothering you? That I know about the baby.”
She pressed her hand to her forehead. “It’s weird. Nobody else knows. Nobody.” He moved in, brushing his fingertips over her forearm. “Don’t,” she said. “Don’t touch me.”
Anger roared through him and he took a step back. Those words cut into him like a knife, and damned if he knew why they landed so deep.
He looked at her face, at the stark fear on it. Fear of him. Of his touch and what it made her feel. And there wasn’t a thing he could do. She wouldn’t let him. He couldn’t even touch her to offer comfort. Couldn’t say what he wanted, couldn’t do what he wanted.
He wanted to hold her. Wanted to kiss her until she forgot. What the hell did she want? To show him her wounds, and then not let him close? To push him away?
He wouldn’t have to be pushed, then.
“Fine, Lane. If that’s how it’s going to be, then I’m going back inside. Maybe I’ll join Liam and Alex—they look like they’re having a hell of a lot more fun than I am.”
And then, feeling like every inch the asshole he knew she thought he was, Finn turned and walked away from his best friend when she needed him most.
* * *
PANIC ROSE UP in Lane’s chest as she watched Finn walk away. She didn’t know what she was doing. Honest to God, she had no idea. But she’d felt like she was falling apart, and sitting there with Cord on the TV while Finn was right there, knowing everything that had happened, was just too much. It was all too much.
Why had she ever thought she should tell him? Well, that was stupid. She knew why. She had told him to shock him, to make him take a step back. To make him rethink wanting her.
But it was more than that. She had also told him to try and prove to him just how important their friendship was. But it hadn’t worked. If anything, she felt more distant from him. And he was walking away from her. He knew she was falling apart and he was walking away. He was making good on what he’d said. That he needed something different than what she was offering and he was tired of hanging around while she continued to ignore that need.
She needed him. What was she going to do if he removed himself from her life? There was nothing she could do. She didn’t have anyone else. Nobody else knew what she’d been through. And she frankly didn’t want to have that conversation with anyone else.
“Wait!” She jogged after him, her heart thundering in her chest, her entire body shaking.
Maybe this wasn’t a new meltdown. Maybe it was just an extended meltdown from yesterday. She should have stayed home. She shouldn’t have agreed to meet him. But she had been so desperate to cement their friendship. To prove that the kissing hadn’t meant anything, that the revelation about her past wasn’t important. That it didn’t have to change anything.
That nothing at all had to change.
Finn stopped, his broad shoulders going stiff. He didn’t turn. “What?”
“Please don’t leave. Please don’t leave me.”
“What is it you want me to say? What do you want me to do? You don’t want me to touch you.” He shook his head. “I’m not going to tiptoe around you.”
“Well,” she said, panic giving way to anger, fury rising inside of her, “that’s your fault.”
Now he turned to face her, more than six feet of enraged male advancing on her now. “My fault? So I was the only one doing the kissing?”
“You started it,” she said, her voice low and trembling. “I didn’t. I never would have started it. Now you know. You know why I have to protect myself like I do. Your friendship is so important to me, and I never wanted to do anything to compromise that. That included touching you. Kissing you. How dare you take that from me? How dare you take away my safe place?”
He moved closer to her and she backed away, pressing her back up against the light post behind her. “I am not your fucking house pet. I’m not some therapy dog you can use to help calm your anxiety. I want things. I don’t exist solely to fill a void in your life. That void that you can’t fill with a husband or a partner because you don’t want a real relationship. So you use some other guy for sex and me to fix your shit. That isn’t happening. Not anymore.”
Angry tears stung her eyes. “That isn’t fair. I don’t think you’re a pet. I never have. But I did think that we were friends. I thought I could trust you. Good grief, Finn, I had you in my house late at night thinking of you like any of my other friends, and the whole time you were trying to scam your way into my pants?”
That was going too far. And she knew it. She hadn’t meant it either. She was just mad, mad and hurt and breaking apart piece by piece, and so she was lashing out at the one person that she wanted to hold on to more than anyone else. It didn’t make any sense, but then she wasn’t sure her emotions had made sense for the past ten years.
“Is that the game now? Because I admitted that I was attracted to you, are you going to act like I was just lying in wait planning to jump on you when I had the opportunity? Here’s some real talk for you, Lane. If I wanted to, I could make you forget all of the issues you have with us getting physical. If I wanted to, I could make you want me. I could make you forget all the reasons it’s not a good idea. I wouldn’t have to coerce you or talk you into a damn thing. You would beg me.”
Suddenly, the reckless heat inside of her changed, melted into something else. Something she couldn’t define, or rather didn’t want to. “Well, aren’t you full of your damn self, Finn Donnelly.” She led with that. With the anger that was still simmering there at the surface, and she left whatever was happening beneath it—all of that molten intensity of feeling that she didn’t want to name—alone for now. “I have never begged a man in my entire life, and you would hardly be the first.”
“Is that right?”
“Yes.” Something small and mean dug at her, spurred her on. “But you’re right about one thing. I have treated you differently than I’ve treated my other friends. My other friends have heard more about my sex life.”
The expression on his face turned sharp, dangerous. “And you want to talk about it with me now?”
“Sure. Why not? You might as well know, since you’re expressing an interest in getting on the ride.” She continued to advance on him, heart pounding, stomach clenched tight, feeling something more than reckless now. “When I want a man, I usually make him take me on a few dates first. Mostly because I want to like the guy that I go to bed with. I’m pretty choosy. I can think a man is hotter than the surface of the sun, but if I don’t want to talk to him at least a little bit, it isn’t going to happen.”