Play With Me, Baby(11)

When her hips began to lift in search of more, I penetrated her with one thick finger and focused my mouth on her swollen bud.

“Oh!” she yelled, her tone filled with shock. Had she never been eaten before? The idea fueled my desire and I sucked her harder and sped up the movement of my finger. I tried to add a second one, but she was so unbelievably tight, it took a little work to get it in there. You’d think she was a fucking virgin with how snug she was. I was going to have to be very gentle with my cock so I didn’t hurt her.

“Your pussy tastes so fucking good, baby,” I growled. “That’s it,” I encouraged as her hips bucked violently. “Fuck my face.”

“Yes! Oh! Oh! Yes!” Her hands fisted in the blankets. Her whimpers and moans were quickly becoming screams of ecstasy, and I was only a breath away from losing it myself.

“Let yourself go, angel,” I growled. “Just give in and let it happen.”

Macy froze for a second, not even breathing, and in the next one, she burst apart. I licked her through her orgasm but didn’t prolong it like I wanted to. I was on the edge, right on the precipice, and I knew I wouldn’t last. I was desperate to get inside her before I blew.

Getting to my feet, I gently moved Macy so she was lying in the middle of the bed as she panted, her body was still shivering from the aftershocks. I ditched my pants and joined her, covering her from head to toe. Her hands roved my body, her face flushed and filled with wonder.

Then her eyes dropped to the thick rod jutting up against my stomach and I waited to see how she would react. Her face reddened and widened with shock, but I wasn’t sure if it was due to my size or the metal bar at the tip of my cock.

I used one leg to nudge her legs apart, forcing them as wide as they would go. One of her hands slid down and tentatively brushed the piercing. “It will feel fucking amazing, angel,” I reassured her. “Just trust me.”

“You’re so big,” she said, worrying her bottom lip between her teeth. “I don’t think you’ll fit.”

“Do you trust me, Macy?”

She immediately nodded, and then her eyebrows shot up when she realized what her instinctive reaction had been. I smiled, overjoyed that she was already putting her faith in me.

Gently, I rubbed the tip of my cock over the lips of her pussy, then up and down between them. I made sure the piercing dragged across her clit and Macy’s hands clasped my biceps while she moaned wildly.

“Do you want me, angel?” I bit out as I held myself back with my last shred of control. I needed her to be sure, to know she wouldn’t wake up tomorrow and regret this. “You belong to me, but if you want more time, I’ll try to give it to you.” I didn’t know how I would accomplish it, but I would do anything for her.

“Once I have you, there is no turning back, Macy.” My voice was stern as the words escaped through my clenched jaw. Her eyes met mine and I felt like I was looking into her soul. “Who do you belong to, angel?” I pressed.

“You,” she whispered.

I thrust my hips so that my whole cock slid against her pussy, rubbing over her hard little clitoris. “Who?” I demanded.

“You! Oh, don’t stop! You!” she cried.

“Right fucking answer, angel,” I growled with satisfaction. I lined my shaft up and slowly began to push in. “You’re so fucking tight, Macy. Shit. Oh fuck.”

“Rhys,” she whimpered, and her nails dug into my skin. “I—um—I haven’t—oh!”

I stared into her eyes as I retreated and then pushed in a little further. She was so small and I was barely an inch inside her. Little by little, she was stretching to accommodate me and I was able to sink in further. Until I couldn’t. Something was stopping my progress—holy fuck! My head reared back in shock and Macy’s expression morphed into a mixture of fear and embarrassment. “You’re a virgin?” I exclaimed.

A tear leaked from the corner of her eye and she looked away as she nodded. Shit. She’d mistaken my astonishment for anger. I pressed a finger to the side of her chin and turned it back to me. Tenderly, I placed a soft kiss on her lips.

“This is a precious gift, Macy, and you have no idea how honored and unbelievably ecstatic I am that you are giving it to me.” I kissed her again and the darkness began to fade from her eyes. “I may not be a virgin, but it’s been a long fucking time, angel. I don’t even remember anyone before you.”

I grinned. “And, it’s the biggest fucking turn on to know I’ll be popping your sweet cherry, being the first and only man to ever be inside your pussy.”