Hearts on Fire 4: Kisses Sweeter Than Pie(26)

Nina held on and tried to counterthrust but it was too much, the sight of her breasts moving with every thrust, her eyes holding his gaze as he clenched his teeth and tried relentlessly to ease the itch, the desire building and building within his cock. He thought he might really explode he felt so full and tight and ready to detonate. Nina caressed his chest, and he eased her lower on the bed, reaching underneath them and stroking a finger over her anus.

“Oh.” She moaned again, the sloshing sound filled the room, and he stroked a finger over her cream then back to her anus and pressed inside of her. Nina shook and moaned deeply and Buddy lost it. One, two, three full, deep strokes and he held himself within her when he came, shooting his seed deeply and imagining her living in their house, sharing their bed forever.

“You’re mine, Nina. Always.” He kissed her swiftly and then hugged her to him as he rolled to the side, taking her along with him.



* * * *



Johnny moved in behind Nina as Buddy eased himself out of her. Johnny kissed along her shoulder and he was pleasantly surprised when she turned, lifted up, and climbed over him.

She sat up, her hands on his shoulders, and looked down into his eyes.

“Hi,” she whispered.

“Hi,” he replied, absorbing the sight of her full breasts and all the love marks along her neck and chest.

He reached up under her hair and drew her down closer for a kiss. She twirled her tongue around his mouth and they battled for control until she jerked.

He released her lips and Nina moaned.

Johnny chuckled. “What is Trent doing to you, baby?”

She eased up and moaned again. “Oh God.”

“You ever have a cock in your ass, Nina?” Trent asked her as he gripped her hips. It appeared to Johnny that he licked along her spine as he pressed his fingers into her ass.

“No. Never.”

Johnny’s heart raced.

“Ever have a dick in your pussy, one in your mouth, and one in your ass at the same time?” Buddy asked, stroking his cock. Johnny knew why. They were going to take her together. His cock hardened beneath her.

She shook her head side to side as she moaned. Johnny lifted her up, aligned his cock to her cunt, and before he could tell her to ease down, Nina did it herself.

“Oh, Johnny.” She moaned out his name as she sunk onto his shaft, taking him inside of her. Johnny tightened up, gripped her hips, and grunted as her pussy muscles gripped his cock.

“Holy shit, you’re so tight, Nina. So fucking tight.”

“She sure is, and we’re going to ease some more lube in this ass and take her together. You’re going to belong to us fully and see that this is real. We’re real,” Trent said, leading the way.

Johnny began to thrust up into Nina and she gripped his shoulders then tried to counterthrust. Buddy moved to the other side of the bed and held his cock in his hand.

“Sweet Nina, I need that mouth.”

“Oh God, this is so crazy. I feel so crazy, wild, and naughty all at once.”

Johnny held her neck and face so she would look at him. “It’s time to get crazy, wild, and naughty with us, your men. Now be a good girl and suck Buddy’s cock while Trent gets your ass ready for his cock.”

He pulled her down as her eyes lit up, and he kissed her shocked expression from her face. He swirled his tongue in her mouth and then thrust upward with his cock, scraping her vaginal muscles.

When he released her, she looked so wanton and wild.

Buddy gripped her hair gently and guided her mouth to his cock. “Ready for you, baby. Nice and easy, you set the pace.”

She licked the tip and Johnny saw Buddy’s cock twitch, heard his brother grunt but hold steady. Johnny thrust upward and Nina opened her mouth and took Buddy deeper.



* * * *



Nina couldn’t believe how she felt right now. Nothing ever made her feel like she belonged, like she was important and special the way making love to these three men did. She tried to keep up with Johnny’s thrusts, but then she was focusing on sucking Buddy’s cock and wanting to satisfy him, make him happy and make him come inside of her mouth so she could swallow his seed and let him know how special he was to her. All three men had ahold of her heart and she wanted to ride this out, enjoy every moment, and live like there was no tomorrow.

She felt Trent pull his fingers from her ass and she gasped with Buddy’s cock in her mouth only to moan when she felt the tip of Trent’s cock push into her anus. His hands were everywhere, caressing and massaging her skin. He had licked and kissed along her scars and she loved him for it. They made her feel so important, but now with a cock in every hole and her body about to lose it, she knew there was never going to be anything as amazing and powerful as these three men making love to her together. She would be ruined after today, and she didn’t care. Instead she focused on them, this connection and the hope that nothing could tear them apart.

“Fuck, baby, I love this ass. This is my ass, Nina.” Trent squeezed her cheeks wider and thrust into her deeply. Johnny was pumping his cock in and out of her cunt while she was trying to keep the same pace sucking down Buddy. Buddy gripped her hair and held himself within her as he came. He tried pulling back but she grabbed his thigh and held him against her, which earned her a caress along her hip from Trent and a squeeze of her breast from Johnny.

Buddy slowly pulled from her mouth and fell back onto the bed. She looked down at Johnny and both he and Trent began a fast pace, pumping into her together. Her arms were shaking. Her legs were, too, when suddenly she exploded, her cream causing both men to penetrate even deeper.

“Oh yeah, Nina. Come for us, baby. Keep coming. Give us all your orgasms,” Trent ordered. She moaned and thrust on top, then felt tinier spasms hit her insides. Her pussy erupted again, and then Buddy leaned over as she sat up and he cupped her breast then stuck his tongue out to lick her nipple then suckled part of her breast into his mouth. The sensation of him pulling the sensitive bud between his teeth while Johnny and Trent continued their strokes made her moan aloud. It was all too much for her.

“Oh!” she cried out and orgasmed again.

“Oh God.” Johnny grunted and thrust upward, held himself within her, and shook as he came. Behind her Trent held on to her hips and ground his cock deeper, faster into her ass. She felt the smack to her backside as he lowered her down onto Johnny, spread her thighs wider, and thrust into her again and again.

“Oh, Trent. I can’t take it.”

“Fuck, I love this ass.” Trent moaned and then came, shooting his seed into her and rocking three more times before he stopped. She felt her ears ringing, her breathing was shallow, and she laid her cheek against Johnny’s chest as he caressed her back and recovered as well.

“So incredible. Damn,” Buddy said. Then she felt his hands caressing her ass and her back as Trent eased out of her.

“Mm.” She moaned.

Then she felt Trent’s lips along her lower back and her ass. “Rest, baby. Rest.”

She closed her eyes and relished in the aftermath of some serious lovemaking by the three sexiest, most compassionate men she’d ever met.





Chapter 7




As Nina finished cleaning up the kitchen from baking her last pie, she thought about Trent, Johnny, and Buddy again. No matter where her thoughts wandered off to, even negative ones, she kept coming back to them. Last night was amazing and this morning? Incredible. They didn’t want her to leave their house, never mind their bed, but she needed to make these pies to fill this order and she also needed a little breather. She had been worried about being clingy or possessive of them and overstaying her welcome, but then Johnny was talking about moving her things into their house and using their industrial oven to cook the pies and how there would be more room.

She couldn’t help but feel tickled at his approach to saying he wanted to spend every waking hour he could with her. Instead she figured she wanted to do this right this time. She needed time to get to know them individually. Although she technically was already doing this backward by sleeping with them and allowing all three brothers to take her at once. She shrugged her shoulders.

Like I care. I don’t regret a single moment. Except maybe falling on my ass and hip. Damn, I think I’m all bruised up from that.

She thought about how Johnny cleaned out the cut on her elbow and how his process of determining if she was indeed okay and not in need of further medical attention led to him taking her from behind while she sucked Trent’s cock.

She shivered and her nipples hardened.

Great, now I’m horny again.

She bent down to pick up the box and felt the ache to her hip and butt. “Ouch.” She rubbed it and tried turning sideways as far as she could to see if there was some bruising. She pressed her shorts down and lifted her tank top up.

“Whatever you’re doing, can I help?”

She gasped as she heard the voice, turned toward the open door, and saw Buddy standing there behind the screen door. He opened it up and walked inside.

“Damn, it smells good in here. I wonder what it is.” He approached and pulled her into his arms. She held onto his forearms and giggled as he sniffed against her neck, tickling her. That led to his hand under her shorts caressing her ass and his other hand under her tank top cupping her breast. He kissed her deeply and she softened in his embrace. When he finally released her lips, her eyes were closed and she felt like putty in them. “I missed you,” he told her.