“I'm thinking that there is something else that neither one of us knows about in the story,” Justin says. “The break in the other night has something to do with this. The DVDs from your house were stolen and Drake drops off a DVD that's a sex video of you. What do you think that's about?”
“Drake broke in?” I say, and it makes sense. “But why? If he had the video at his house, what would he be looking for here?”
Justin looks at me and takes a lock of my hair and tucks it behind my ear. “I love you, Jenna,” he tells me, “but I think I need to talk to Kate now.”
“You mean-?”
He nods. “Can you just let her come out and talk?”
I nod and feel her consume me.
*
“Kate?” she hears him say. “Can we talk?”
She smiles and rakes her fingers through her hair. “What I want to do involves more than talking.” She leans over and starts to push Justin down onto the mattress but he stops her.
“No, I can't do that with you,” he says. “I love Jenna, Kate, but I don't love you.”
Kate scowls at Justin. “Jenna is a part of me,” she explains. “If you love Jenna, you love me too.”
Justin shrugs. “Perhaps I do, but I think it would be a violation of Jenna's trust to touch you...like that.”
“Well then,” she purrs. “I guess we're not going to talk.” She gets up and begins to open drawers, pulling out clothes.
“What are you doing?”
“I'm going out,” Kate explains. “Since all you want to do is talk, and I find that boring, and I'm horny.”
“Charming,” Justin says. “What can I do for you to get you to talk to me?” He stands up and takes a hot pink lacy bra out of her hand and puts his arms around her waist. “Anything?”
She grins and laughs. “Oh, Justin, you're terrible at manipulation. But fine, since you're asking. I'll give you what you want, but you have to do what I want.”
“I can't do that to Jenna,” Justin explains. “If you're asking for what I think you're asking for.”
“You won't know until after I tell you. Then you have to do exactly what I want. And it will not involve leaving your clothes on. Or mine. In fact, let's play it tit for tat.” She pulls her shirt up. “I'll start with some tit.”
Justin looks at Kate. “It's scary how much you look like Jenna, but you aren't.” He sighs. “Fine. Tit for tat. You get to start. What do you think Drake was looking for when he broke in and took the DVDs?”
“That's a loaded question,” Kate says. “First you're assuming that it was Drake.”
“Who else could it have been?”
“Perhaps any of the men who were videotaped with Jenna back when Jack used to record her and get paid to do it.” Kate smiles slightly. “Don't look so shocked. Jack did whatever he could for money. The video was just another method for profit.”
“So you think those videos are somewhere in this house?” Justin asks.
Kate shakes her head and puts her finger against his lips. “Not just yet,” she says. Now it's my turn.”
“Okay,” Justin agrees. “Fair enough. Tell me what I should do.”
“First,” Kate says. “Get naked. I want to see how hard you get.”
Justin reluctantly begins to take his shirt and pants off and stands naked in the middle of the room. Kate grins and opens the closet door and Justin hears her rummage around. When she comes out of the closet, she is holding a huge red dildo in her hands. “Now,” she says, “I want you to fuck me with this until I come.”
Justin sighs. “Okay,” he agrees. He takes it out of her hands and inspects it. Besides it being about nine inches long it's about two and a half inches around in girth.
“Get it nice and wet in me,” Kate says. “The wetter it is the less painful it will be when it's inside of you.”
Justin's eyes practically pop out of his skull. “Um, no. You can't expect me to-”
“You will if you want to hear everything,” Kate snaps, laying herself down on the bed. She positions herself as though she might be going through a gynecological exam, and Justin notices she's so wet, she's literally dripping on the sheets. “Get it inside of me, and if you feel any resistance, force it in. Push hard.” Justin slowly walks toward her and presses the tip of the dildo against her. He pushes it up from the bottom of her slit to the top to collect all of her wetness. “Ohhhh,” Kate moans. “You seem like you've done this before.”
“No,” Justin says through his teeth. He feels ashamed for betraying Jenna, and most of all, ashamed for how hard he is getting. She is Jenna, he tells himself. Everything I do to Kate, I'm doing to Jenna. With that thought in mind, he pushes the tip so it slowly sinks inside of her, making Kate gasp and arch her back. “Don't resist,” Justin says sternly. “The harder you resist the more I will push and tear you apart if I have to.” His hand moves to his cock and he begins to rub the glistening tip with the palm of his unoccupied hand while he moves the shaft of the dildo deeper inside of her, pushing it in slowly and out. He can feel her loosen up.