Lord Vader spoke up. “At one time I would have said that such words were nonsense, if not close to treason. However, I’m forced to admit that Prince Xizor may speak truth. I would not have had the difficulties that I’ve experienced with the Imperial high command if their brains were not addled with cowardice. But then, if your admirals were wiser creatures, the Death Star would not have been destroyed so easily.”
“Precisely so.” Things were going better than Xizor had hoped; to have Vader agree with him about anything was a surprise. “The Empire, by its very nature, destroys that which it needs to grow and survive. Take the Imperial stormtroopers, for example; you have trained them to obey, to fight, and to die in the service of the Empire … but not to think. The same holds true with practically everyone else throughout the Empire’s chain of command, right up to the topmost ranks; most of your underlings, my lord, lack any creative spark,
any capability of deep analysis or real cunning; that’s all been beaten out of them, crushed by your power. But the fledgling elements of the Rebellion do possess those characteristics; that’s why they’re in the Rebellion. Foolish they may be, to the point of being suicidal; nevertheless, their rebellious nature is exactly that which makes them a threat to the Empire.”
The
Emperor nodded, mulling over Xizor’s words. “You’re very eloquent on this matter. I don’t have to worry about you showing initiative, do I?” Palpatine raised his head, showing his unpleasant smile. “So what would you have me do about my servants? Perhaps I should just be … kinder to them. Would that work?” Sarcasm turned his voice darker and uglier. “Or else I should just throw away the power I hold over them. But then, what power would I have left?”
“It’s not a matter of throwing away power, my lord. Even as they are, your servants have their uses. A hammer doesn’t need a mind or a spirit to fulfill the purpose of he who holds it. Your admirals obey your orders; that is sufficient for them. The Imperial stormtroopers are tools for creating the desired level of terror on your subject planets; they would be less terrifying if they were capable of thought. But they are like machines, right to the core that no longer exists in them; set upon their course, they obey and die and kill, with no possibility of swaying them from their orders, by appeal to reason or emotion. That is how it should be; that is how these servants are most useful to you and to the Empire’s glory.” With a nod of his head, Xizor indicated the stars slowly wheeling behind the throne. “Nothing is achieved by throwing away those tools, my lord, however limited their uses may be. But what you must find are other tools, ones that are not within the absolute grasp of your power.”
“I think,” said the Emperor, “that I already have such tools, and such servants. Standing here in front of me.”
“Just so.” Lord Vader’s image regarded Xizor for a moment, then turned again toward the Emperor. “And you must decide whether such a tool’s usefulness is greater or less than the danger it represents to the Empire.”
Back to where we were before, thought Xizor. If Vader had appeared to agree with him, it had been only for a moment. And only for the purpose of driving another wedge between the Emperor and any of Vader’s rivals for influence. Someday he and I will come to grips with each other. With grim determination, Xizor looked forward to that confrontation with Darth Vader. And then we’ll settle things, once and for all.
The Emperor spoke up. “When that happens,” Palpatine said coolly, “it will be a judgment laid upon you as well, Lord Vader.”
“Let your judgment be on our accomplishments, my lord.” Xizor’s gesture took in both himself and Vader. “And on our service to you. But as I said, the Empire requires other servants and tools. And those cannot be such as your stormtroopers and admirals, or even such as Lord Vader and myself. To destroy the Rebellion, to crush once and for all the resistance that has grown against your power, you must employ those who have sworn no loyalty to you.”
“I think, Prince Xizor, that you may be increasing the dangers to the Empire rather than lessening them.”
“Then I have yet to make my meaning clear to you, my lord. Extraordinary times require extraordinary measures. The day will come when the Rebellion is no more, when your grasp of all the galaxy’s worlds will be final and never-ending. Then you will have no need of servants and tools with minds of their own. You may, perhaps, have no need of me. But that is no concern of mine; my fate is nothing compared to the glory of the Empire. But that time is not yet here. In this time you must take into your hand the most dangerous tools. If a vibroblade’s edge is sharp enough to cut both ways, then he who uses it must be careful. But the only thing more dangerous than picking it up is the failure to do so.”