‘Was the cart abandoned?’ Athelstan asked. ‘What happened to its escort?’
‘By all the saints,’ Brokersby exclaimed, ‘that was years ago! What does it matter now?’
‘Because, my friend,’ Cranston shouted back, ‘if it was proven, even now, that the Passio Christi was stolen from the Abbey of St Calliste that renders you excommunicate, whatever the number of years. You would still be proclaimed public sinners and stripped of everything. You might even hang. So tell us,’ Cranston added quietly.
‘We found it in a cart,’ Wenlock answered coolly.
‘No escort?’
‘Nothing, just plunder of war waiting to be taken.’
Athelstan sighed noisily. ‘That is your story.’
‘We are our own witnesses,’ Mahant declared. ‘Who else is there?’
‘Tell us,’ Cranston asked, ‘why should two of your company be so barbarously slain?’
‘We don’t know,’ Osborne declared.
‘We are old soldiers serving our time,’ Mahant added.
‘So why go armed in this abbey?’
‘Because Sir John, this abbey is not what it appears to be.’ Osborne threw off Brokersby’s warning hand.
‘You think these good brothers are united in prayer? Well, look at the facts. The abbot hates the prior who responds with as much loathing. The prior loves the Frenchman Richer with a love not known even towards women. Our Lord Abbot is more concerned about that nasty swan than he is about the rule of St Benedict. He keeps his beloved niece, if that is what she really is, in the guest house guarded by that old harridan. Meanwhile Richer slips in and out of this abbey like a rat from its hole. We’ve seen him wander down to the watergate. Was he there when poor Ailward was murdered?’ Osborne breathed in heavily, wiping the white flecks of foam from his lips on the back of his hand. ‘Then there’s that anchorite, mad as a March hare, in the abbey church, screaming that he is haunted. He has grudges against us, as do Prior Alexander and others who, I am sure, have great sympathy for the Great Community of the Realm and their leaders the Upright Men. Now two of our comrades are foully murdered, certainly not by us. Why not make your enquiries amongst the brothers: Abbot Walter, Prior Alexander, Richer the Frenchman? After all, we’ve seen military service, but they’ve also done their fair share of spilling blood. They can wield swords.’ Osborne’s voice trailed off in a fit of coughing and throat clearing.
‘Do you see Richer as your enemy?’
‘No, Brother, but he may view us as his.’
‘So why are you armed?’
‘Because,’ Wenlock intervened, ‘three weeks ago, just before the beginning of Advent, I was attacked out in the abbey grounds. I have a passion for herbs and shrubs – I always have. I visited the gardens and afterwards I went for a walk. Nearby runs a maze, its high hedgerows, all prickly, laid out in a subtle plan. A former abbot had built it so those who could not take the cross to Outremer to fight the infidel could crawl through its maze of narrow paths to the centre where there is a Great Pity surmounted by a cross. I entered but dusk was creeping in. I was about to leave when a figure charged out of the gloom, hooded and masked, sword and dagger whirling. I was petrified; all I carried was a pilgrim staff.’ Wenlock grimaced. ‘The forefingers of both my hands are maimed, the French, God curse them. I cannot pull a bow but still, albeit clumsily, wield a weapon.’
‘You fought your assailant off?’
‘I was out looking for Wenlock,’ Mahant spoke up. ‘I heard the shouting, the slash and clatter. I answered Wenlock’s cries of ‘Aux aide! Aux aide!’ By the time I arrived his assailant had fled; from that time on we decided to go armed.’
‘And you reported all this to Father Abbot?’
‘I might as well have talked to his stupid swan!’
‘And you have no idea of your attacker?’
‘No, he was dressed all in black, cowled and masked.’
‘Or why you were attacked, at that time, in that place?’
‘None whatsoever.’
‘Have any of you,’ Athelstan persisted, ‘relatives outside this abbey?’
‘Not that we know of, we are old soldiers. Some of us were married but now our wives are dead.’ Mahant’s voice turned wistful. ‘Whatever children we had lie cold beside them.’
‘As do two of your comrades?’
‘Brother, Sir John?’ Wenlock’s voice turned pleading. ‘We are finished, surely?’
‘I would like to inspect the chambers of the dead men.’ Cranston rose swiftly to his feet. ‘And that includes William Chalk’s.’ Cranston gestured towards the door. ‘Now, sirs. With you or without you . . .?’