I reached down and felt the outline of his cock underneath his jeans. Jonathan moaned in my ear and nibbled on my neck as I stroked his shaft. His hands reached under my blouse and felt up my tits. I lifted it over my head and unsnapped my black lacy bra. Jonathan's eyes went big as my bountiful breasts were released.
Jonathan immediately buried his face in my cleavage, running his tongue over my peaks. He squeezed them as hard as he could until they were about to pop. He flicked my nipples back and forth with his tongue until they were hard and pointy. He sucked on my nipples like a baby wanting milk. I moaned as I held his head against my chest. The passion between us was on fire.
"Take off your pants," Jonathan commanded.
I did as he asked while Jonathan took his jeans off. I reluctantly took off my panties and set them on the car floor. We were both completely naked and just stared at each other. There was a thick attraction in the air between us.
Jonathan's cock was big and erect like I always dreamed it would be. Jonathan leaned back in the middle of the back seat. "Get on top of me," he instructed.
I lifted myself up onto Jonathan and straddled him. His pulsing cock was pinned under my wet pussy. I rubbed against him, lathering up his shaft with my wetness.
"Fuck me now," Jonathan begged.
This wasn't how I pictured my first time. I thought it would be more romantic. Music and candlelight. Not in the backseat of Jonathan's old '97 Honda Civic.
I kissed him and wanted to stay in this moment with him forever. "Put on a condom first."
Shock flooded Jonathan's face. "I didn't bring one, Lucy."
I stopped kissing him. "What do you mean?"
"I forgot. I didn't think we would be doing this tonight."
"But you brought me out here all the way in the middle of nowhere. You planned that far ahead but you didn't think to bring a condom." I sat on his lap and tried not to think about his thick meat below me.
"Don't worry about it, baby, I'll just pull out."
I cocked my head at him. "I don't know, Jonathan, maybe we shouldn't do this."
He reached up and kissed me again. "Do you trust me, Lucy?" he asked.
I looked in his blue eyes and couldn't help it. "Yes," I replied.
I lifted up while Jonathan held his cock straight up. I gently lowered down, fighting against the pressure as his cock tried to penetrate me. Jonathan pushed hard until he broke through. I cried out in pain as Jonathan slowly filled me up.
"Oh my fucking god, you're so tight, Lucy."
I bounced up and down, fighting through the pain until the pleasure took over. Then it was over all to fast.
Jonathan's nails dug into my sides as he unloaded his seed inside me. I jumped off of him but it was too late. His warm cum was already running out of my pussy and drying on my thighs.
"What the fuck, Jonathan! You were supposed to pull out."
"Sorry, but I was lost in the moment. Didn't it feel good?"
"Of course it did. But that's not the point! What if I get pregnant?"
"Don't worry. Nobody ever gets pregnant on their first time."
Jonathan was so wrong.
When my period went missing and my belly began to swell, Jonathan was nowhere to be found. He was the typical guy. My step stepdad, Harrison, and my mom were devastated. They supported me every step of the way.
I had to drop out of my senior year of high school. It was an easy choice to give up the baby for adoption. I was too young and had no way of caring for a child. It made it even easier that there was no father in the picture. That's no way for a baby to grow up.
After the baby was born and given away, I was pretty devastated. Not that my baby was gone, but that almost a whole year of my life had been wasted. My friends had stopped talking to me and I still had to repeat my last year of high school.
My parents did there best to cheer me up.
"Hey Lucy, do you want to hang out with me today?" Harrison asked, peeking his head into my bedroom.
I didn't feel like getting out of bed most days. This was no exception. "I think I'll just rest some more," I told him.
Harrison opened my door all the way and burst into the room. He flung the curtains opened and let the sunlight flood the room. My eyes burned and I threw the comforter over my head. "Come on, Lucy, you can't hide in here forever. Your mom is going on a business trip for a couple of days and I don't want to be bored. Let's go downstairs, order a pizza, and watch a crappy movie."