Babysitters Erotica Collection(43)

I licked all of her come and slid a finger inside her. I felt her tense but she spread her legs to allow me to explore her freely. She was slick yet very tight, my finger feeling a bit of snug resistance. I was getting so hard this time. I would love to feel that tightness around my cock, to plunge into her depths. I just don’t know if I should.

I pulled my finger out completely then gently pushed it again, all the while kissing her navel. She was meeting each thrust with enthusiasm so I thrust another finger inside and increased the pace of my deliberate caress. She was moaning again and her sounds were driving me so wild. I raised one leg on my shoulders so I can go even deeper and true enough, she responded even wilder than my previous moves.

I crawled on top of her and kissed her breasts again, her hand pushing me even closer to her. I sucked her nipples and she whimpered, begging me to suck her even more. Her hand is grabbing my cock, which is still rock hard, and is desperate for some hard fucking. For the first time in my life, I was torn about what to do. As much as I wanted her physically and I am dying to go inside her, the innocence and worry I see in her eyes make me hesitate.

The way she was squeezing my rod was just unbearably pleasurable that I closed my eyes and imagined I was already inside her. She must have felt me hesitating and whispered, “Please take me, Keith. Please.”

I looked at her eyes which are now filled with lust and she won me over. I positioned myself right in her entrance and started to enter her, little by little. She spread her legs, welcoming me without any hesitation. My fear of hurting her subsided when she reached out her arms to me and encouraged me to go deeper. I slid bit by bit and felt her tensed. “Now, Keith. Now!”

I plunged totally and closed my eyes as I felt something tore inside her. I froze for a moment watching her. She smiled at me and nodded. “Did I hurt you, Nancy?”

“No. But you’d hurt my feelings if you stop now.” She giggled and held on to my shoulders.

I started to move again inside her, loving her snug sleekness and the way her hips move with me. I moved in and out of her, focusing my weight on my arms. I screwed her cunt gently, and she bucked her hips against mine, her breath coming in fast and short patterns. Her legs wrapped around my waist, encouraging me to go faster. My rod threatened to explode but I increased my pace and moved in and out of her until we couldn’t take it anymore. She dug her nails on my back as I moved faster and faster inside her. “Don’t stop, Keith. Oh don’t stop!” I closed my eyes and focused all my strength on my cock pleasuring her as much as I can. She was writhing and moaning and her eyes were semi-shut. I felt her pelvic muscles tighten and I realized I was so close to coming. “I’m coming Nancy!” My entire body shook as I spilled everything inside her. She came a second after that and I held her tightly to calm her down.



We held each other tight for a while, waiting for the quake to subside. She snuggled up beside me and kissed me deeply. “I’m no longer a virgin.”

I hugged her tightly. “Aren’t you mad at me for taking it all away- I mean your, you know.”

“You kidding me? That was like THE BEST thing ever. Will you take me again?”

“That depends.”

“On what?”

“If you’ll hate me afterwards.”

“I don’t get you.”

“You know-because I hurt you a few minutes ago.”

“Shut up. It’s not that I’m scarred for life. Besides, what happened afterwards is worth a few seconds of minimal pain. It didn’t even hurt that much.”

“Really?”

“Yeah. Really. It’s no big deal okay? And it’s not as if you forced me. I came willingly and I was the one who spread my legs. Now stop acting like a kid and take me again.” She started giggling then. “Oops. I got carried away.”

I spanked her lightly at the butt and held her tighter.

“What about your boyfriend?” I nudged even more.

“What about him? And it’s ex-boyfriend-former boyfriend.”

“You’re no longer a virgin anymore. I think he’d be more than willing to take you now. Are you thinking about going back to him?”

“Hmmmm it depends.”

“Depends on what?”

“How much more of this nonsense questions will you keep on asking me. Ask me one more and I’ll come crawling back to him right now.” She looked at me and pouted. “Please don’t give me away too easy.”

She really is indeed the prettiest girl I have ever seen. I covered her with blankets and opened my bottom bedside drawer to retrieve some cookies and chips. “You must be hungry.”